But what to do about Avatar. . . .
The Hurt Locker gets my vote for the components of which Best Pictures are usually comprised, but Avatar feels to me like another kind of Best Picture--the kind that enlarges our sense of what films can do.
There should be a special category of Oscar for such pictures: an award for Special Achievement in Film-making, Boundary Breaking, something like that.
It would honor extraordinary and innovative artistic achievement in a film as a whole--in contrast to typical Special Achievement awards, a new special effect or technological breakthrough wouldn't suffice--and it wouldn't be given every year. Foreign films and docs would be eligible, and the winner could also be chosen as Best Picture.
I'd have given such an Oscar to Citizen Kane.
How about you?